President Donald Trump as he departs the White House, in Washington, DC, on June 2, 2019, and former US vice president Joe Biden during the kick off his presidential election campaign in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, on May 18, 2019. JIM WATSON,DOMINICK REUTER/AFP/Getty Images


Analysis banner

  • President Donald Trump is trying to drag former Vice President Joe Biden’s name through the mud ahead of an election year and amid an escalating impeachment inquiry.
  • Trump in a July 25 phone call urged Ukraine to investigate Biden and his son.
  • Trump’s primary allegation is that Biden squeezed Ukraine into firing its top prosecutor to the benefit of his son, but there’s no evidence of this.
  • Even still, there’s growing evidence Trump’s efforts are successfully sowing doubts about Biden.
  • Biden’s campaign advisers are worried that Trump is winning the messaging battle, as polling simultaneously shows a significant cohort of voters believe Biden probably pressured Ukraine to fire the prosecutor on his son’s behalf.

The Ukraine scandal and related whistleblower complaint pose an existential threat to Donald Trump’s presidency.

The revelation that Trump urged a foreign power, in this case Ukraine, to investigate former Vice President Joe Biden has sparked an impeachment inquiry in Congress.

But the controversy also has the potential to sow doubts and suspicion around Biden, despite no evidence of wrongdoing on his part, and there are already signs that it’s begun to.

Trump seems to be looking to his 2016 playbook in this regard.

Throughout the 2016 campaign season, Trump sought to malign former Secretary of State Hillary Clinton, his top opponent, by constantly focusing on her use of a private email server.

Biden is a top contender for the 2020 Democratic nomination and an unapologetic critic of Trump, and the president appears to be employing a similar tactic as he seeks to divert attention away from the impeachment inquiry and discredit the former vice president.

And history tells us this strategy just might work.

Ukraine is the new ‘but her emails’

clinton trump
Republican presidential nominee Donald Trump (L) and Democratic presidential nominee former Secretary of State Hillary Clinton during the town hall debate at Washington University on October 9, 2016 in St Louis, Missouri. Getty


Though the FBI characterized Clinton’s use of a private email server as “extremely careless,” it concluded she did not commit any criminal wrongdoing. To this day, Trump has not let the issue go, and even alluded to it in the phone call with Ukraine at the heart of the whistleblower complaint. And he really hammered Clinton on it during the campaign, at one point suggesting he’d jail her if elected.

It’s hard to know exactly how much of an influence the focus on Clinton’s emails ultimately had in her 2016 loss to Trump, which was a product of a convoluted array of factors and occurred despite her winning the popular vote.

But when Clinton left her post as Secretary of State in 2013, she had a whopping 69% approval rating. Within just a few years she would go on to become the second-most unpopular major-party presidential nominee in modern US history, surpassed only by Trump in this regard. And polling during the 2016 campaign season showed that Clinton’s handling of the email scandal was hurting her with voters — including Democrats.

Biden could potentially suffer similar consequences as Trump seeks to make the Ukraine scandal a story about the former vice president rather than his efforts to have a political opponent investigated.

There’s no evidence to back up Trump’s allegations against Biden, but that might not matter

Trump Biden
US President Donald Trump (L) shakes hands with former US President Barack Obama (C) and former vice-President Joe Biden after being sworn in as President on January 20, 2017 at the US Capitol in Washington, DC. MARK RALSTON/AFP/Getty Images


The whistleblower complaint centers around a July 25 phone call between Trump and Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky. On the call, Trump urged Ukraine to investigate Biden regarding the former vice president’s role in seeing a prosecutor fired at the same time that his son, Hunter Biden, served on the board of a powerful Ukrainian gas company, Burisma Holdings.

Trump’s primary allegation is that Biden squeezed Ukraine into firing its top prosecutor to the benefit of his son, but there’s no evidence of this.

It’s true Biden pressured Ukraine to fire the prosecutor, Viktor Shokin, and as part of these efforts he at one point threatened to withhold $1 billion in loan guarantees from Ukraine if Shokin wasn’t pushed out.

But the former vice president was actually among a large number of US and European officials to push for the ouster of Shokin — and the European Union hailed his dismissal — as he was widely viewed as far too soft on rampant corruption in Ukraine. Moreover, by the time Shokin fired there were no active investigations into Burisma.

Long story short, Trump’s allegations against Biden are without and evidenced foundation.

Even still, more Americans seemingly believe Biden probably pressured Ukraine to fire Shokin to help his son than those who say he probably didn’t, according to a recent Monmouth University poll, which suggests the narrative Trump is pushing is taking hold.

Monmouth found 42% of Americans say Biden “probably did exert this pressure” and 37% say this probably did not happen.

Meanwhile, the new prosecutor general in Ukraine on Friday announced he is reviewing past investigations into the owner of Burisma. This raised the possibility of inquiries into the gas company tied to Biden’s son being restarted.

The Ukraine scandal is rapidly escalating, and a second whistleblower with first-hand knowledge of some of the allegations outlined in the complaint has also come forward.

As reported by Business Insider